Showing posts with label Not recommended. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Not recommended. Show all posts

Friday, December 10, 2010

UNITED STATES OF TARA - SEASON ONE (a review)

UNITED STATES OF TARA - SEASON ONE (a review)



A tv show from Diablo Cody, the stripper turned writer who won an Oscar from Juno. The story is about a wife with multiple personality disorder. Stars Toni Collette, John Corbett, Brie Lawson.

The story: (since this is a series, there isn't a specific storyline but here's the jist...) A housewife with multiple personality disorder tries to go off her meds to learn to deal with her disorder and get to the cause of it, struggles with her family -- her incredibly understanding husband, her annoying sister, her slut daughter and her gay son -- as they struggle with not only the chaos of a mom who is constantly changing, but also with their lives -- the daughter has an abusive boyfriend and then gets a job where the manager tries to sleep with her and the son has a crush on a Christian who may or may not be gay.

Was it good?

It was okay. It's never great. There are times it tries to be shocking or daring, but those are all kind of awkward. The strange thing that makes it watchable is the way that amid all the chaos of what's going on the family still comes off as fairly normal. While most shows with families are completely unrealistic -- and the more normal the family the more unrealistic the show feels (*cough* Cosby Show *cough*), this show with it's completely out-there premise actually helps make the characters and family feel normal.

This normalicy makes the show very watchable. If you are doing something and it's in the background, it's easy and enjoyable to follow. Still, as a show there never is anything compelling enough to allow me to recommend it. It's frustrating because this seems to be the modus operandi with a lot of the cable shows nowadays -- they are interesting but never that compelling.

So why is this mediocre-good while SEX AND THE CITY was so compelling, or SPARTACUS or BURN NOTICE? Well, the problem comes from two questions every writer should think about -- what is it about and how far do you push it?

What it this show about? The multiple personality thing is okay, but for non-multis what does it mean? In other words, what are we, the audience, supposed to take from it? The thing I get out of it is that even with all the choas they are normal...which is fine, but it's not much of a statement. In fact, it's a total non-statement because it's about them. Good statements (in fiction) are statements that affect the viewer. They are statements that the audiences take with them into their own lives. This doesn't have that sort of statement. You'd think they would use the multi as a metaphore for the ways a woman gets pulled in every direction, the way every woman needs to be many different people to be a woman and a mom...but no. It's used mainly just to make her life more chaotic. So what it is about? A normal family. And that's about it.

How far do you push it? This isn't just about being outrageous. This is about knowing whta the series is about and pushing and pushing the story to get deeper to the heart of what it is that you are exploring. Except here the story is just that they are normal. It's hard to push that. You can surround them with more chaos, but tat just feels like more and more stuff. So things like the sister having had a bad boob job...meh. So while the series is enjoyable it never gets to greatness because there just never seems to be anything at the heart of it.

So, no I can't recommend it. But I understand why others would find it enjoyable.

*** NOT RECOMMENDED ****

Monday, October 25, 2010

4.3.2.1 (2010) (a review)




This is the story of four girls, best friends, who all have their own individual stories that overlap and combine as they become involved in a crime ring that includes stolen diamonds. A girl-centric version of PULP FICTION? A thriller version of SISTERHOOD OF THE TRAVELLING PANTS? Or just a weird sort of jumbled mess? Stars Emma Roberts, apparently trying to break away from her sweet HOTEL FOR DOGS image.

The story: four friend sit in a diner eating before heading off for their own individial adventures -- one is going to an audition (and to lose her virginity), one is dealing with her parents' non-acceptance of her lesbianism, one is being forced to work in a convenience store after her father breaks his leg, and the other is dealing with her mother leaving her father (and her). However, outside the diner, a man running from the police stores stolen diamonds in one of their purses and now through these stories the girls will be pursued by criminals to get the diamonds back.

Was it good?

Not really, but it wasn't horrible. Most movie suffer because they don't try to do anything -- they are just running on plot. This movie tries to do TONS of things. Some work okay, others don't work at all.

The first problem is that none of the individual stories is particularly good. Even the best one -- a girl goes to America to audition for some acting coach and meet with with a guy she wants to lose her virginity to, but then after having sex with her he robs her, so she tracks him down and beats him up some only to have him get out and attack her, so she runs and he catches her, but then a local girl calls her friends to rough the guy up -- doesn't really go anywhere. Maybe the idea is that all these girls learn to stand up for themselves, but it seems like the only way they stand up for themselves is with physical violence and it seems weird to say the way to find empowerment is to commit assault. For instance, with the virginity-and-robbery guy, she doesn't call the police and doesn't get her stuff back (as far as I can remember). So...yeah, the guy will get roughed up, but she's still out all her stuff, her money and her virginity.

The other three stories seem to have even less to them. One has Emma Roberts working in a store where there's the arrogant good looking guy and the nice guy, but it doesn't really go past that. The store gets robbed and you're back to the crooks.

Now I guess the overlapping stories was supposed to be one of the cool elements, and the stories did a good job of interweaving. There are multiple times you see the same event from a different perspective and every time it adds to the story...not an easy thing to do. At the same time, because the individual stories go basically nowhere, the movie as a whole feels repetitious. If the idea was to do female empowerment (something repeated a few times), then they needed to watch more SEX AND THE CITY. In S&tC they will have one key issue -- like, is lying good for a relationship -- and then each of the four women will deal with it in a different way. Here, there isn't any clear theme, no central thematic question. That lack of clarity hurts the movie overall and the writing of the individual stories.

In the end, while there was stuff to like, there wasn't enough good -- and definitely not enough great -- for me to recommend it. But I wouldn't actually tell people to avoid it either as I think a lot of people will find it interesting.

*** NOT RECOMMENDED ***